Los periódicos latinoamericanos sólo sobrevivirán con la ayuda del Estado, pero no precisamente por la publicidad que los gobiernos publican en ellos, escribe para el Huffington Post Eduardo Bertoni, un analista experimentado en materia de medios.
“Los gobiernos deben adoptar políticas públicas claras para fortalecer la democracia mediante, por ejemplo, el otorgamiento de subsidios y beneficios fiscales a favor de los periódicos”, escribe Bertoni, director del Centro de Estudios en Libertad de Expresión y Acceso a la Información de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad de Palermo, en Argentina. Bertoni fue también relator especial para la Libertad de Expresión de la Organización de Estados Americanos.
Los modelos de financiamiento que están siendo explorados y puestos en práctica en otras regiones –por ejemplo, contenidos pagos, anunciantes privados e ingresos procedentes de donaciones– no representan una solución viable para América Latina.
“La idea de transformar a las empresas de periódicos en especies de organizaciones no gubernamentales (ONG), sostenidas con los ingresos de donaciones generosas, no funcionará en América Latina. Tal estructura es posible en países donde un grupo sustancial de personas está dispuesto a donar recursos para esta clase de proyectos y donde existen marcos legales claros y predecibles que permitan inversiones seguras en el mercado bursátil. Es poco probable que esta combinación pueda darse en América Latina”.
Lea la nota completa de Bertoni (en inglés) aquí. (Vía Periodismo de las Américas)
Journalism in Latin America: Who Should Pay the Bill?
What’s Your Reaction:
digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost – stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS
Important
Fascinating
Typical
Scary
Outrageous
Amazing
Infuriating
Beautiful
Read More: Latin America , Latin America Democracy , Latin America Journalism , World News
5
vote
nowBuzz up!
Get Breaking News Alerts
* Share
*
Comments 3
Latin American countries need good quality journalism to protect, consolidate, and strengthen democracy. Historically associated to investigative journalists working for newspapers, good quality journalism is expensive and now faces serious challenges due to the unprecedented financial crisis affecting newspapers worldwide. If we agree that democracies need good journalism, somebody needs to pay the bill.
The only realistic — and unfortunately very risky — means for newspapers’ survival is to receive help from the state. None of the other options, including that readers pay for their papers, private advertisement, and revenues from an endowment, will work in Latin America.
There has been an increase in the circulation of paid newspapers in several countries. Almost 2 billion people around the world read paid newspapers every day. However, revenues coming from subscriptions or daily payments are not enough to ensure papers’ financial sustainability.
Private advertisement has been falling dramatically. According to the World Association of Newspapers, only from 2008 to 2009, newspaper advertisement revenues dropped 21% in North America, 16% in Western Europe, and 6% in Latin America. This trend, which began some years ago, will continue while newspaper advertisement moves to the Internet, and the numbers of web advertisement continue to increase.
The idea to transform newspaper companies into some sort of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that would be supported by the revenues from a wealthy endowment will not work in Latin America. Such structure is possible in countries where a substantial group of people is willing to donate funds for this sort of projects, and where there are clear and predictable legal frameworks that allow for secure investments in a financial system such as a stock market. It is unlikely that this combination would exist in Latin America. But even if it did, the recent world financial crisis shows that this model is very risky.
Many Latin American newspapers have been historically supported by state funds, specifically through public advertisements. But when a state pays for public advertisement, it is not promoting a public policy to ensure independent journalism — it is simply paying the media to publish information that it believes should be in the public domain. In addition, a major problem with public advertisement, in practice, is that public officials in Latin America have typically allocated it in a discriminatory fashion, as an indirect sanction to papers with an editorial line critical of the government.
So how should Latin American governments pay the bill? The focus should not be on allocating public advertisement, even if it is done in a transparent and non-discriminatory way. Governments must adopt clear public policies to strengthen democracies by, for example, granting subsidies and tax benefits in favor of newspapers. Clearly, the experience regarding how Latin American states have allocated public advertisement should serve as a model — of what should not be done when drafting and implementing these new, necessary policies.
Eduardo Bertoni
Director, Center for Studies on Freedom of Expression at Palermo University School of Law
Former Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression at the Organization of American States (2002-2005)
